Some 65 Christmas presents for the needy stolen in the burglary of a Violet church were returned by the St. Bernard Parish Sheriff’s Office on Wednesday, Dec. 23, after a 45-year-old Violet man – on parole for a previous burglary conviction – was booked with the Dec. 20 break-in, Chief Deputy Sheriff James Pohlmann said.
Herman “Peter’’ Smiles, 2505 St. Matthew’s Circle, which is near the burglarized Our Lady of Lourdes Catholic Church in Violet, was arrested at his home about 3 a.m. after sheriff’s detectives, who had been concentrating on the case since the burglary, acted on a tip, and found all of the stolen presents in a bedroom of the home Smiles shared with relatives. Detectives had been concentrating on the case since the burglary.
Smiles was booked with burglary of a religious building and parole violation. He is being held in St. Bernard Parish Prison and no bond has been set.
“It’s a good ending to a terrible incident,’’ Pohlmann said, saying it was “good police work’’ by sheriff’s detectives that broke the case. “I can’t say enough about our detectives, commanded by Chief of Detectives Col. John Doran. They ran down leads, with help from other departments of the Sheriff’s Office, until an arrest was made and virtually all stolen items were recovered.’’
Smiles, who served time in prison on an aggravated burglary conviction out of St. Bernard and has been on parole since 2006, confessed to the church burglary under questioning and said he did it in hopes of finding money to obtain illegal drugs, Pohlmann said, adding he took the presents for possible sale on the streets.
“He broke in to look for money’’ after he had been smoking crack cocaine earlier that night, Pohlmann said, adding that investigators believed someone committing such a desperate act was likely a drug addict looking for a means to buy more drugs. “We’ve said before that if you could solve the drug problem you could solve the crime problem.’’
Smiles, who has had a number of arrests since the 1980s, described himself to sheriff’s detectives as having problems with both drugs and alcohol.
Smiles also said he acted alone, using a concrete stepping stone to break a window to enter the church about 2 a.m. and sat down for nearly an hour as he opened the presents that were under a statue of Jesus on a cross at the rear of the church, put them in garbage bags and made two trips to carry them to his home. Pohlmann said.
One present, directly under the cross, was left untouched by the burglar and some people had speculated afterward that maybe a last-minute feeling of guilt had overcome the culprit. But when asked why he had left it, Pohlmann said, Smiles replied he must not have seen it.
The suspect had a wound on his left hand, which matched up with the fact that blood was left on a floor and other areas in the church as the burglar entered through the broken window.
The presents, which were in five black garbage bags under Smiles’ bed, were returned to the church at 2621 Colonial Boulevard by the Sheriff’s Office. Sheriff’s deputies, like numerous others in the New Orleans area who were outraged by the theft of presents for the needy and responded by donating to the church to replace the gifts, also brought cash donations and bicycles to the church on Dec. 23.
Our Lady of Lourdes Pastor John Arnone, who had said for days that church officials appreciated the public’s response to the burglary, said he had believed the break-in would be solved. “I was thrilled’’ about the arrest, Arnone said. “I knew it would happen. It was because of the work of the deputies that it happened.’’
The priest also said, “I still pray for conversion of that person”
involved in the burglary. “It’s unfortunate when people go to these types of extremes because of addictions.’’ Our Lady of Lourdes Church, hard-hit by Hurricane Katrina like nearly every building in St. Bernard Parish, had only reopened in late November.
Detectives focused on another person of interest in the case who, when questioned early in the morning of Dec. 23 gave information that Smiles was the church burglary, Pohlmann said.
A consent to search was obtained at Smiles’ residence and detectives found all of the 65 missing presents – mostly clothing, shoes and toys – in his room.
He allegedly intended to sell some items and keep others. But selling the stolen items off so soon after the robbery would’ve been hard, Pohlmann said. Potential buyers would’ve been reluctant about becoming involved in such a high-profile case or possibly would’ve tipped police off that someone was in possession of items likely taken from Our Lady of Lourdes.
Members of Our Lady of Lourdes congregation had worked to identify needy children in their community then bought them Christmas presents, wrapped them and planned a giveaway.
After word spread of the crime, people from across the metropolitan area and as far as other states showered the church with new presents and cash donations. By Tuesday night, gifts were piled on the floor and the Boy Scouts in Metairie donated 15 bicycles. The Salvation Army also stuffed nylon crawfish bags with toys.
Our Lady of Lourdes, it turned out, amassed a mound of presents much larger than officials ever expected. The giveaway was to be held Wednesday night.
